Learning hub · Human Performance
Stress, arousal and workload
Stress is not the enemy. A pilot with no pressure at all is bored and careless. The trouble starts when the demands of the flight outrun the attention you have to meet them. This lesson looks at how stress changes what you notice, and at the one skill that matters most when the cockpit gets busy: deciding what to drop.
About 14 minutes, plus the quiz. Part of Human Performance. It builds on the short stress section in Decisions, stress, alcohol and medication.
1. What stress is, and where it comes from
A stressor is anything that puts a demand on you. Stress is your body and mind responding to it. Some stressors are in the aeroplane: noise, heat, turbulence, a rough-running engine, a busy frequency, a checklist you do not know well. Some are in your head: fear of looking foolish, a check ride, a passenger watching you. And some have nothing to do with flying at all: a row at home, money worries, a deadline at work, too little sleep.
- Acute stress arrives quickly and fades when the cause goes: a bump on short final, a missed call. The body reacts at once.
- Chronic stress builds over weeks and does not switch off when you leave the office. It uses up your reserve, so ordinary cockpit tasks cost more than they should, and it is a common reason that people sleep badly, which adds fatigue on top.
The body’s response is the old fight-or-flight reaction. Stress hormones such as adrenaline are released, the heart and breathing speed up, muscles tense and the mouth goes dry. In small amounts this helps. It becomes a problem because it also changes how you think: attention narrows, you hold fewer things in mind at once, and the quickest idea feels like the best one. Fast, shallow breathing can also tip into the hyperventilation covered in the first lesson.
2. The arousal curve, and its limits
You will see a picture of an upside-down U in every human factors book. Performance is poor when arousal is very low, best at a moderate level and poor again when arousal is very high. It is usually credited to Yerkes and Dodson, who in 1908 gave mice electric shocks of different strengths while they learned to tell two boxes apart. What they actually reported was that the best level of shock depended on how hard the task was: easy tasks did well with stronger motivation, hard tasks did better with weaker. The tidy inverted U that is now drawn came later, and psychologists have argued ever since about how far it can be pushed.
Two ideas survive the arguments, and both are useful to a pilot:
- The best level depends on the task. A simple or well-practised task copes with more arousal. A new or complex one is spoiled earlier. This is why a calm student can fly a good circuit and then fall apart on an unfamiliar airfield with a fast controller.
- Attention narrows as arousal rises. This is often linked to a psychologist named Easterbrook, who proposed in 1959 that stress cuts the range of cues you can take in. Under heavy stress you fix on one thing, such as the runway threshold, and stop seeing airspeed, traffic or the fuel gauge.
Treat the curve as a picture, not a law. It does not measure any individual, people differ, and skill and experience move the whole thing. The widget below is a teaching model.
Try it: move the slider and switch between a simple and a complex task. The green band is the best zone for that task. Watch where the dot falls and how the share of cues you still notice shrinks.
This model needs JavaScript to move. In words: performance is poor at very low arousal, best at a moderate level and poor again at very high arousal. A simple task peaks at a higher arousal than a complex one, and attention narrows as arousal rises.
3. Coping: avoid, reduce, cope
A useful way to sort the answers is in three steps, in this order:
- Avoid the stressor. Do not fly tired, rushed or after a bad night; skip the flight, or fly with an instructor. Do not accept a flight you have not planned. Decide your personal minimums on the ground.
- Reduce it. Plan early, brief before busy phases, set up the radios and the airfield information before you need them, and fly the aeroplane you know.
- Cope with what is left. In the moment, slow your breathing, with a long steady breath out, and tell yourself the next step. Talk through the checklist aloud. Ask for help: ATC would much rather give you time or a vector than hear nothing.
When you do not know what to do next, fall back on the order aviate, navigate, communicate. Fly the aeroplane first, then work out where you are and where to go, then talk. It is not a rule about who matters most. It is a reminder of what you cannot afford to drop.
4. Workload: demand against capacity
Workload is the demand that tasks put on you against the attention and time you have. Think of a bucket: the water coming in is the tasks, and the size of the bucket is your capacity. Capacity is not fixed. It is smaller when you are tired, new to the aeroplane, stressed or out of practice.
When the demand fills the bucket you reach task saturation. The dangerous part is not that you stop working. It is that you do not choose what to drop. Attention lets go of whatever is least noticeable, and that is often the quiet job with no alarm: the lookout for traffic, a glance at the altitude, a check of the fuel. A radio call or a passenger’s question demands attention loudly and wins.
The remedy is task shedding: deliberately dropping the least important jobs so the important ones stay inside the bucket. That means knowing the order of priority beforehand, which is aviate first, then navigate, then communicate, and the rest below. “Stand by” is a complete answer to a passenger, and an ATC call can often be answered with “unable” or a request for time.
The other remedy is better: spread the work so it never piles up. Brief the landing and do the descent checks in the quiet part of the flight, before you are in the circuit.
Busy phases and quiet ones
Workload is not even. The heaviest moments are take-off and departure, joining a circuit or arriving at an unfamiliar airfield, a go-around, a diversion and any change of plan. Long, empty cruise sits at the other end: too little to do invites boredom, a wandering mind and missed calls. Both ends cost performance, which is the same inverted U seen from the side of workload.
Equipment moves the load around rather than removing it. A tablet or autopilot can take work off you in cruise, and the same tablet adds heads-down work if you have to find the frequency in a busy circuit. The sensible use is to set everything up on the ground. A device is a help only while you are still looking out of the window.
Try it: fly an arrival. Each task takes some attention each minute, and you have 10 units. Set what to do earlier and what to shed, switch on the options, then fly it and read the debrief.
This game needs JavaScript. In words: on a busy arrival the tasks add up to more than you can handle. Move the checks and the briefing earlier, shed the optional tasks such as the passenger’s chat and the tablet, and keep the traffic lookout going.
5. In the cockpit
- Brief in the quiet. Do the descent checks, the arrival brief and the go-around plan at the top of descent, not on downwind.
- Say your priority aloud. “Aviate, navigate, communicate” is short enough to use when your head is full.
- Know what you will shed. Decide in advance: passenger chat first, then the tablet, then non-essential calls. Never the lookout.
- Buy time. An orbit, an extended downwind, a request to ATC for a vector or a hold costs little and takes load out of the worst minutes. A go-around is a reset.
- Watch for the signs of saturation in yourself: tunnel vision on one item, skipped checks, rushed or clipped radio calls, short temper, a feeling of being behind the aeroplane. When you notice them, simplify first.
- Look after your reserve. Sleep, food and water are workload tools. Chronic stress is a reason to be more conservative about whether to fly, and a reason to talk to someone.
This is training material, not medical advice. If stress, anxiety or low mood is affecting your sleep or your life, speak to your doctor, and ask an aeromedical examiner (AME) how it affects your medical certificate before you act on any medication.
6. Common mistakes
- Treating stress as weakness. Everyone feels it. What matters is what you do when you notice it.
- Believing the curve means “more pressure makes me sharper”. Past the peak, every extra bit of pressure costs performance, and you are the last to notice.
- Dropping the lookout and the instruments first because they are quiet, while answering every call and question.
- Saving the briefing for the circuit, when it can be done ten minutes earlier.
- Fixating on one problem, such as a rough engine, and forgetting to fly the aeroplane to a landing place.
- Carrying on with a plan that has stopped working because a change feels like failure.
7. Key points
- Stress is the body’s response to demand. Acute stress is quick and passes; chronic stress builds and lowers your reserve.
- The arousal curve is a picture, not a law. The best level is lower for hard or new tasks, and attention narrows as arousal rises.
- Avoid the stressor, reduce it, then cope with what is left.
- Task saturation means you stop choosing what to drop. Shed on purpose, from the bottom of the priority list.
- Aviate, navigate, communicate.
- Plan and brief in the quiet. Set up your tablet and radios on the ground.
- Ask for time. It is almost always available.
8. Check yourself
Five original practice questions. Answer them, press Check answers and read each explanation.
Up next: hazardous attitudes and risk perception. Back to the learning hub.