Guide for student pilots
Go or no-go: a weather decision checklist for student pilots
Make the go or no-go decision on the ground, against numbers you wrote down beforehand. A flight is a go only when every figure is inside the regulation, your school’s rules and your own personal minimums, with some room to spare.
A learning aid, not advice for a particular flight. Your instructor and your school’s manual decide your limits. Where this guide gives numbers, they are invented for illustration.
1. Three layers of limits
Every flight has to clear three limits, and the strictest one wins.
- The regulation. For visibility and cloud, see VFR weather minima under SERA. These are the lowest figures that are legal. They are not a target.
- The aircraft and the school. The flight manual, the operator’s rules and your school’s limits for students, for solo flights and for navigation flights. These are often tighter than the regulation.
- Your personal minimums. Limits you set for yourself, with your instructor, based on your experience. They are the only layer that moves as you learn.
2. Set your personal minimums
Write them down, on paper or in your planning notes, before you look at the weather. A number you have already committed to is much harder to talk yourself past on the morning of a flight. Start cautious, agree the figures with your instructor, and raise them slowly as you gain experience. Lower them again after a break from flying.
| Item | What to write down | Example, invented |
|---|---|---|
| Flight visibility | The lowest you will accept for the flight | 8 km |
| Cloud base | The lowest base above the ground along the route and at the destination | 2,000 ft |
| Crosswind | The most you will accept on the runway, counting gusts | 10 kt |
| Daylight | How much margin you want before sunset at the planned landing | 30 minutes |
| Your own state | The conditions on which you do not fly | Ill, tired, rushed or after alcohol |
These examples are not a recommendation. Your figures come from your school and your instructor.
3. The checklist, in order
- Are you fit to fly? Illness, medication, alcohol, stress, tiredness and hunger all count. If the answer is no, the weather does not matter.
- Get the actual weather. The METAR and the TAF for the departure, the destination and the alternate, and the winds for your level. Note the time of each. If you need help with them, read how to read a METAR and TAF.
- Compare each number with its limit. Visibility, cloud base and crosswind, one line each. Use the gust, not the mean wind, for the crosswind.
- Look at the trend. A TAF that is improving or worsening matters as much as the present numbers. Look for fog risk, showers or thunderstorms, a front arriving and anything that will bite when you return.
- Think about the way out. If the cloud comes down on the route, where would you turn back, or land? A flight with no good exit needs a bigger margin.
- Check daylight. The sunset time, and the time you would really land if everything runs a little late.
- Decide, and tell someone. Say your decision to your instructor or to someone on the ground. A decision said aloud is harder to drop quietly.
4. Try a check
Enter the weather for the flight and your own limits. The result reads each line against its limit. A figure that passes but sits close to its limit is marked “think again”, because forecasts are wrong and conditions change.
Go or no-go check
All the numbers start as invented examples. Replace them with your own.
5. Two worked examples
Both use the invented limits from the table: 8 km, 2,000 ft and 10 kt.
- Visibility 7 km in haze, cloud base 2,500 ft, crosswind 11 kt with gusts. Visibility is below the 8 km limit, so that is a no-go on its own. The crosswind is also over its limit. The cloud base is fine, but one failed line is enough. Do not fly.
- Visibility 9 km, cloud base 2,300 ft, crosswind 7 kt. All three are inside the limits. Visibility is within a fifth of its limit and so is the cloud base, so the result is “think again”. A better answer might be to wait for an hour and read the next METAR, or to fly only a short local flight with your instructor.
6. What “think again” means
- Delay, and read the next report. Weather that is improving may be fine in an hour.
- Change the flight: a shorter route, a different destination, a local flight near the airfield, or a flight with the instructor on board instead of solo.
- Cancel, and treat it as a good decision. A cancelled flight costs a day. The wrong flight can cost far more.
Be wary of pressure. A booked lesson, a friend waiting or a long drive to the airfield all push towards “go”, and none of them change the weather.
This page and the check above are a learning aid. They do not replace a proper weather briefing, your instructor’s decision or the regulations that apply to you. VectorEFB is not certified for navigation.
Next: crosswind limits for student pilots. See also how to plan a VFR cross-country flight and all the guides.
VectorEFB shows the weather on one map and keeps your plan for your instructor to review. Request access while it is in private pre-launch.