Learning hub · Human Performance
CRM, situational awareness and threat and error management
Crew resource management began as a way for airline crews to use everything and everyone on the flight deck. For a student or private pilot it comes down to something simpler: seeing what is really going on, spotting the threats before they find you, and using every defence you have, including the instructor, the controller and your own checklist.
About 16 minutes, plus the quiz. Part of Human Performance. It follows Hazardous attitudes and risk perception.
1. What CRM means when you fly alone
Crew resource management (CRM) is the use of all available resources, people, equipment and information, to fly safely. In an airline it covers communication, leadership and decisions between pilots. You may think a single-engine aeroplane with one pilot has no crew. It has more than you think. The resources are your instructor or the pilot beside you, the controller or the information service you talk to, the checklist, the flight manual, the charts and your tablet, the passengers, and a fellow pilot on the ground you can phone. Using them well is the whole skill.
Three things matter most, and the rest of this lesson takes them in turn:
- Situational awareness: knowing what is happening and what will happen next.
- Threat and error management: finding the things that could go wrong, and catching your own mistakes.
- Communication and assertiveness: saying what you see, and asking when you do not understand.
2. Situational awareness: three levels
Situational awareness (SA) is a word for knowing what is going on around you. A widely used description, by the researcher Mica Endsley, splits it into three levels that build on each other:
- Perception. You notice the facts: the altitude, the fuel in each tank, the other aeroplane on the screen.
- Comprehension. You understand what they mean. Altitude 240 ft lower than ten minutes ago means a slow descent, not noise.
- Projection. You work out where this leads. At that rate, where will you be when you reach the hill?
Most errors of awareness start at level 1, but the dangerous ones are at level 2 and 3: the pilot saw the number and never asked what it meant. A pilot who only perceives is a passenger with a good view.
How awareness is lost
- Attention narrows under stress or high workload (see Stress, arousal and workload). You stare at one item and the rest drops out.
- Complacency. On a familiar route nothing has gone wrong for hours, so you stop checking.
- Interruptions. A radio call in the middle of a checklist breaks the flow, and the item you were on is forgotten.
- Expectation. You hear the clearance you expect, not the one given, or you see the runway you expect.
- Heads-down time. A tablet, a chart or a phone takes your eyes out of the window just as traffic closes.
Keeping it
- Scan in a pattern and include the engine and fuel, not only the horizon and the map.
- Ask “what will this be in ten minutes?” at every change.
- Cross-check two sources: gauge against calculation, tablet against chart, heading against landmarks.
- Say it aloud: “fuel left 34, right 40, left tank”. Speaking forces a check.
- If you are unsure where you are, treat it as a problem now. See map reading and getting lost.
Try it: three rounds, each with two frames a little apart in time. One thing changes. First find it, then say what it means, then say what will happen if nothing changes. Use the flicker button if you like. It is normal to miss a change at level 1. That is the point of the exercise.
This exercise needs JavaScript. In words: in each round one item changes between two frames: a slow descent towards a hill, a fuel selector left on one tank, or traffic on a constant bearing. Spotting it is level 1, understanding it is level 2, and working out the result is level 3.
3. Threat and error management
Threat and error management (TEM) is the working model behind modern CRM. It has three parts:
- Threats are things outside your control that raise the risk. Weather worse than forecast, a short or wet runway, high terrain, busy airspace, a hurried passenger, a tired instructor, an unfamiliar aeroplane, time pressure to be home.
- Errors are your own actions or omissions that depart from what you intended: the wrong frequency, a missed checklist item, a wrong fuel figure, a switch in the wrong position.
- Undesired aircraft states are what happens when a threat or error is not caught: low and slow on final, off track into controlled airspace, fuel low. They can still be recovered. Left alone they become an incident.
The aim is not a flight with no threats or no errors. Nobody has one. The aim is to find threats early, trap errors before they matter, and recover from the undesired state. The sorting is simple: name the threat in the briefing, plan what you will do about it, and if an error slips through, catch it with a cross-check.
Three tools
- Avoid the threat. Do not go, go later, pick another route or another airfield.
- Trap the error. A checklist, a read-back, a fuel dip, a second look at the chart: each is a net under a mistake you will sometimes make.
- Mitigate the result. Have an escape: an alternate, extra fuel, a go-around plan, a height to turn back.
4. The Swiss cheese model
The psychologist James Reason described accidents with a picture. Each defence is a slice of cheese: a briefing, a weather check, a checklist, a fuel check, your awareness, the instructor or the radio. Every slice has holes, but not in the same place. A hazard goes through a hole in one slice and is usually stopped by the next. An accident happens on the day the holes line up and the hazard goes straight through.
Two lessons follow. First, more layers means fewer accidents, and skipping one defence matters more than it looks, because it is the one that would have been covering for another. Second, holes are not fixed. The holes are tiredness, haste, a skipped briefing, trust in a single gauge. They open on bad days and move.
Try it: pick a hazard and switch defences on and off. Move the holes to see a different day. Watch how many hazards get through the whole row when you switch off a layer or two. This is an illustration. Real defences are not independent, and a real pilot cannot see the holes.
This model needs JavaScript. In words: six slices of cheese in a row stand for briefing, weather check, checklist, fuel check, situational awareness and instructor or radio. A hazard passes through a hole in one slice but is stopped by the next solid one. With every defence on it is rare for any hazard to get through. With several switched off, many do.
5. Communication and assertiveness
Many accidents had someone who knew something was wrong and did not say it, or said it so softly that it was not heard. In a two-seat trainer the instructor is a resource, and a student who stays silent wastes it.
- Say what you see. “I do not have the traffic.” “The fuel is lower than I planned.” Do not wait to be sure.
- Ask, and keep asking. “Say again” is a normal radio phrase. If you do not understand a clearance, ask for it again, or say “unable”.
- Read back what you must, and listen to your own read-back. Most wrong readbacks are heard by the pilot who made them only after the controller corrects them.
- Be assertive without being rude. State the concern, the fact behind it, and what you propose: “I am uneasy about the cloud base. It is lower than forecast. I suggest we turn back.”
- Take a correction. Being told you have made an error is information. Defending yourself costs seconds you may need.
- Brief the passengers. Tell them what you expect them to do and say, and that they should tell you if they see traffic or feel unwell.
The same applies in the other direction. If you are the experienced pilot with a student or a less experienced passenger, make it easy for them to speak up: ask “what do you see?” and do not treat a question as a challenge.
6. In the cockpit
- Brief threats, not only the route. Before engine start, name the two or three things most likely to hurt you today and what you will do about each.
- Use your checklists as the net they are, and restart the item you were on after an interruption.
- Set triggers. “If the cloud base is below 1,500 ft at the pass, I turn back.” Decide it on the ground, and keep it.
- Verbalise the picture. Say or think the three levels at each waypoint: what I see, what it means, what comes next.
- Use ATC and the information service. A traffic information service or a flight information frequency is a resource. A call early is better than a call late.
- Debrief every flight. What was the best decision? Where did a hole nearly line up? What would I change? The learning is in the next flight.
This is training material. It does not replace the human factors course of your approved training organisation or an instructor’s judgement. The exercises are simplified teaching models, not tools for use in flight.
7. Common mistakes
- Thinking CRM is for airline crews and does not apply to a one-pilot flight.
- Perceiving a change and not asking what it means or where it leads.
- Treating a checklist as a ritual to read through, instead of a check of the real aeroplane.
- Skipping a briefing or a fuel check because it has never mattered before. That is the hole.
- Not speaking up because the other person is senior, or because you might be wrong.
- Treating an error as a reason for embarrassment instead of an item to fix and tell your instructor about.
8. Key points
- Your resources include the instructor, ATC, the checklist, the charts, the passengers and the aeroplane itself.
- Situational awareness has three levels: perceive, understand, project forward.
- Awareness is lost through narrowed attention, complacency, interruptions, expectation and heads-down time.
- Threats come from outside, errors from you, and undesired states from the two left unchecked. Avoid, trap and mitigate.
- Accidents happen when holes in several defences line up. Keep every layer, especially on the day you feel you do not need it.
- Say what you see and ask what you do not understand.
- Debrief every flight, and treat errors as information.
9. Check yourself
Five original practice questions. Answer them, press Check answers and read each explanation.
Back to the learning hub.